ALLEGEDLY*
THE MORGUECASE CLOSEDSeptember 19, 2026
▶ PLAY THIS CASE BLIND Loads the redacted lede with the answer hidden. Three strikes, same as the day it ran.

Case No. 56: Phil Rudd

In 2014 this hard-rock drummer telephoned a man in New Zealand and told him he was coming over to kill him — a call that cost him eight months of home detention and, for a while, his seat behind one of the biggest bands on earth.

The full story

Phil Rudd pleaded guilty in Tauranga District Court, New Zealand, to threatening to kill and to possession of methamphetamine and cannabis, and was sentenced on 9 July 2015 by Judge Thomas Ingram to eight months' home detention. In September 2014 he had asked an associate to have a former employee 'taken out' and then phoned the man directly with a threat; a charge of attempting to procure murder was withdrawn. A police search of his Tauranga property on 6 November 2014 found 0.48g of methamphetamine and 91g of cannabis.

The clues we handed out

— Police searching his property also found methamphetamine and cannabis. He pleaded guilty to those counts too.

— A far more serious charge — attempting to procure a murder — was withdrawn before it reached trial.

— The court heard the trigger was the commercial failure of a solo album he had just put out.

— The band toured without him, and then took him back.

— Initials: P.R.

How this case played

ALLEGEDLY* edition No. 56. Three strikes to name Phil Rudd, with a free clue unlocked after every miss.

More closed cases from the Music desk

CASE No. 53September 16, 2026 In December 2025 the governor of Tennessee pardoned this tattooed country-rap singer from Antioch for the felonies of his youth — … It was Jelly Roll CASE No. 46September 9, 2026 A New York judge ruled in 1976 that this former member of a very famous band had copied a girl-group hit from 1963 for one of his … It was George Harrison CASE No. 42September 5, 2026 A Los Angeles jury decided in 1994 that this big-voiced balladeer had lifted a 1960s soul record for one of his own hits — and han… It was Michael Bolton CASE No. 34August 28, 2026 Crossing the line at the 2026 London Marathon in three hours twenty-one, this green-skinned witch of a 2024 blockbuster was met by… It was Cynthia Erivo

Every closed case from the Music desk →

🗞️ PLAY TODAY'S EDITION ← THE MORGUE
*A blind item you can check. Every puzzle is drawn from the public record — court records, official rulings, and moments that unfolded on live television — and the records are linked above. Allegedly.
Privacy Policy · Terms of Service · Cookie Policy · Sitemap