ALLEGEDLY*
THE MORGUECASE CLOSEDOctober 5, 2026
▶ PLAY THIS CASE BLIND Loads the redacted lede with the answer hidden. Three strikes, same as the day it ran.

Case No. 72: Lindsay Lohan

Between 2007 and 2012, this child-star-turned-tabloid-fixture racked up two DUI arrests, multiple rehab stints, and a no-contest plea for walking out of a Venice jewelry store wearing a $2,500 necklace.

The full story

Lindsay Lohan's legal run included two 2007 DUI arrests and a 2011 no-contest plea to misdemeanor theft of a necklace from a Venice jeweler, with sentences spanning probation, house arrest, and community service. She later rebuilt her career with Netflix romantic comedies and a Freaky Friday sequel.

The clues we handed out

— Her courtroom appearances became fashion coverage — one white dress she wore to a hearing sold out within hours.

— Her breakout Disney role required her to play twins. Both of them.

— Her most famous movie clique wore pink on Wednesdays.

— She staged her comeback via a string of Netflix holiday rom-coms.

— Initials: L.L.

How this case played

ALLEGEDLY* edition No. 72. Three strikes to name Lindsay Lohan, with a free clue unlocked after every miss.

How players did

33 people have played this edition. 31 of them named Lindsay Lohan — a 94% solve rate. Of those who got there: 10 on the lede alone, before a single clue, 7 after one clue, 14 after two.

The jury's verdict

Every case that closes goes to the jury. Players who finished this edition were asked: Has enough time passed to let it go?

11 verdicts have been filed. 91% would let it go. 9% say not yet. Close to unanimous.

See how the jury ruled on every closed case →

More closed cases from the Film desk

CASE No. 71October 4, 2026 Mid-sentence during a 2006 television interview, this European filmmaker was shot — by an air rifle, fired from a nearby building.… It was Werner Herzog CASE No. 68October 1, 2026 In February 2009 this Oscar-nominated actor shuffled onto a late-night couch behind an enormous beard, mumbled through the strange… It was Joaquin Phoenix CASE No. 63September 26, 2026 In 1984 customs officers at a London airport opened this American leading man's luggage and found cocaine tucked inside a can of s… It was Stacy Keach CASE No. 57September 20, 2026 Between pictures, this 1940s screen star sat down with a composer and co-invented a frequency-hopping system for guiding torpedoes… It was Hedy Lamarr

Every closed case from the Film desk →

🗞️ PLAY TODAY'S EDITION ← THE MORGUE
*A blind item you can check. Every puzzle is drawn from the public record — court records, official rulings, and moments that unfolded on live television — and the records are linked above. Allegedly.
Privacy Policy · Terms of Service · Cookie Policy · Sitemap