ALLEGEDLY*
THE MORGUECASE CLOSEDOctober 7, 2026
▶ PLAY THIS CASE BLIND Loads the redacted lede with the answer hidden. Three strikes, same as the day it ran.

Case No. 74: Robert Smith

Told that fans were being charged service fees that nearly doubled the $20 tickets he had insisted on, this English frontman said publicly that he was sickened — and had the fees refunded inside a day.

The full story

For The Cure's 2023 'Shows of a Lost World' North American tour, Robert Smith refused dynamic pricing and set face values as low as $20. When tickets went on sale on 15-16 March 2023 fans posted screenshots showing four $20 tickets totalling $172.10 with fees. Smith said publicly he was 'sickened' and that artists have no control over fees. Within about a day Ticketmaster agreed the fees had been unduly high, automatically refunded $10 to every buyer of a lowest-tier ticket and $5 to every other buyer, and cut fees on remaining sales.

The clues we handed out

— Four twenty-dollar tickets were coming to $172.10 once fees were added. Fans posted the screenshots.

— He had already refused dynamic pricing for the tour and set the face values deliberately low.

— The ticketing company conceded the fees had been unduly high and refunded $10 to every buyer of the cheapest tier.

— His band has been going since the late 1970s, and he has worn much the same eyeliner throughout.

— Initials: R.S.

How this case played

ALLEGEDLY* edition No. 74. Three strikes to name Robert Smith, with a free clue unlocked after every miss.

How players did

37 people have played this edition. 21 of them named Robert Smith — a 57% solve rate. Of those who got there: 5 on the lede alone, before a single clue, 16 after two.

More closed cases from the Music desk

CASE No. 75October 8, 2026 Told to get the booed singer off the stage at a 1992 tribute concert, this songwriter and actor walked out to her instead and said… It was Kris Kristofferson CASE No. 70October 3, 2026 At 92, this mathematician turned songwriter put every lyric and every score he had ever written online and told the world to help … It was Tom Lehrer CASE No. 65September 28, 2026 In June 2024, this former boy-band frontman was pulled over in the Hamptons after a hotel dinner and told officers he'd had 'one m… It was Justin Timberlake CASE No. 60September 23, 2026 Caught with heroin in a hotel room, this veteran guitarist walked out of court without a day in prison — the judge instead ordered… It was Keith Richards

Every closed case from the Music desk →

🗞️ PLAY TODAY'S EDITION ← THE MORGUE
*A blind item you can check. Every puzzle is drawn from the public record — court records, official rulings, and moments that unfolded on live television — and the records are linked above. Allegedly.
Privacy Policy · Terms of Service · Cookie Policy · Sitemap